I had not heard of a sugar cream pie. My wife picked one up at the farmers market. We were very disappointed to say the least. Pie had absolutely no flavor. The only flavor was from the cinnamon sprinkled on the top. Have since heard the same complaints from other people. Definitely won't go back. And we have a sugar cream pie since then from somewhere else and it was to die for. Also very rich. But tasty.
They would have had my money if they took credit card. Be warned: CASH ONLY at this establishment. Pies look delicious, but I rarely carry cash. Looks like I'll have to stop by an ATM before visiting my family in Indy.
Worth the trip if you don't live locally. Blue Ribbon pies and cobblers of all sorts
OMG This place is wonderful. Call ahead to order what you want, or stop and pick up from daily selection. Sugar creme is great, favorite at our house. Very reasonable price.
I think Lisa would get a bunch more money if she accepted credit cards!! Just some advice ;)
World famous pies and they are the best in the area. Wonderful selection. Must order early for the holidays.
Lisa S Pie Shop is a US Bakery based in Atlanta, Indiana. Lisa S Pie Shop is located at 5995 US-31, Atlanta, IN 46031, USA.
Please contact with Lisa S Pie Shop using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Lisa S Pie Shop opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.